Gin is neutral spirit flavored with botanicals, and juniper has to be the loudest one in the room. Take juniper out and you've got vodka with herbs. Keep it in and the rest is a recipe: coriander, citrus peel, angelica, orris, cardamom, whatever the distiller decides. Every style of gin is a different recipe for that same idea.
The styles split on what the other botanicals get to do. A juniper-forward gin keeps them in support, and a contemporary gin lets them lead. These are the ones that matter:
Coriander seed: citrus and pepper. The second most important botanical after juniper in nearly every gin.
Angelica root: earthy and woody. The "binder" that ties the others together.
Orris root: a fixative. You rarely taste it directly, but it holds aromas in place.
Citrus peel: lemon, orange, grapefruit. The brightness lever.
Cassia / cinnamon: warmth.
Cardamom: increasingly common in contemporary gins, and it can dominate fast.
London Dry is the default. "Dry" means no added sugar after distillation, and "London" describes how it's made, not where, so London Dry can legally be made anywhere.
Flavor: juniper-forward, often with prominent coriander and citrus peel. Crisp, and not subtle. It was the backbone of nearly every gin cocktail until about 2000.
Plymouth sits between London Dry and New Western. It's made only in Plymouth, England, by one distillery, and that distillery still defines the style even though its protected geographic status lapsed in 2015.
Flavor: softer juniper, earthier, and a little sweeter, with more root and angelica, so it's less aggressive than Tanqueray.
Use it in: anywhere London Dry feels too sharp. The Gimlet is the classic match, and it's excellent in a Negroni.
What to buy: there's only one, Plymouth Gin. If you make a lot of gin cocktails, the Navy Strength version (57%) is worth owning too.
Genever is the granddaddy of gin. It's Dutch in origin, made from a malt-wine base (think distilled beer mash) redistilled with juniper, and it's closer to a young whiskey with juniper than to modern gin.
Flavor: malty and grain-forward, with juniper present but not dominant. There are two main styles, and the names describe the recipe, not how long it aged:
Oude (old): at least 15% malt wine. Traditional and oily. The good stuff.
Jonge (young): leaner and more neutral, a post-WWII style. Skip it unless a recipe specifically calls for it.
Use it in: classic genever cocktails (Improved Holland Gin Cocktail, Holland House). It's also excellent neat or on the rocks.
What to buy: Bols Genever (oude), Old Duff Genever, Boomsma Oude. None are easy to find outside cocktail-focused stores.
Old Tom is the historical bridge between malty Genever and bone-dry London Dry: lightly sweetened, sometimes barrel-aged.
Flavor: rounded, softer and maltier than London Dry. The juniper is less aggressive.
Use it in: the Tom Collins (where Old Tom historically makes sense), the Martinez, and any pre-Prohibition recipe that calls for "gin" and tastes weird with London Dry.
What to buy: Hayman's Old Tom, or Ransom Old Tom (barrel-aged, developed with the cocktail historian David Wondrich).
Contemporary gin is everything from about 2000 onward that pulls juniper back and pushes other botanicals forward: citrus, cucumber, florals, tea, whatever.
Flavor: all over the map, depending on which botanicals the distiller puts up front.
Use it in: the Gin & Tonic is home base, since these gins were designed to play with tonic, and they suit highballs generally. Go carefully in the classics, because a gin that sidelines juniper gets lost in a Martini.
What to buy:
Hendrick's: cucumber and rose, made for G&Ts.
Monkey 47: piles in 47 botanicals, Black Forest ones among them. Dense and expensive, and people love it or hate it.
St. George Botanivore: wildly herbal American craft, an herb garden in a glass.
Aviation American Gin: softer and citrus-forward, an easy gateway from vodka.
Navy Strength is less a style than a strength: usually a London Dry bottled at 57% ABV (114 proof) instead of 40 to 47%. The story goes that navy gunners needed gin that could spill on gunpowder and still ignite. It's almost certainly folklore, and the term itself only dates to the 1990s.
Flavor: the same gin, louder. More juniper, more body.
Use it in: anywhere you want gin to win the fight. Citrus-heavy sours, heavy-tonic G&Ts, a Martini you want to remember tomorrow.
What to buy: Plymouth Navy Strength, Fords Officers' Reserve (a little lower, at 54.5%), Sipsmith VJOP, Hayman's Royal Dock.
A Martini is gin, vermouth, and ice, so there's nowhere to hide. If your gin's lead note is cucumber or floral water, your Martini tastes like cucumber-floral water with vermouth somewhere in the back.
Juniper is strong enough to stand up to vermouth's bitterness and the dilution from a long stir, and it pairs naturally with the herbal notes in a good dry vermouth.
It's the same reason a Negroni made with Hendrick's doesn't quite land. Campari is loud. Hendrick's isn't.
There's no single right gin-to-tonic ratio, but two work well:
Spanish-style: 1:3 in a giant balloon glass with a lot of ice and a generous citrus garnish. The ice keeps it cold and dilutes slowly, and the wide bowl holds the gin's aroma where you can smell it.
British-style: 1:2 in a highball. Less tonic means the gin comes through louder.
High-end tonic matters more than high-end gin. Fever-Tree Indian, Fentimans, or any small-batch tonic transforms even a $20 gin, and cheap tonic ruins a $50 one.