A cocktail is base spirit plus modifier plus seasoning. Bitters are the seasoning, and modifiers are the small bottles (Chartreuse, Campari, maraschino) that give liquor an identity. The trick with both is knowing which few to buy first.
Bitters are botanicals (bark, root, peel, spice) infused into high-proof spirit and used by the dash, like salt. They tie a drink together so it stops tasting like its parts side by side, and they make the flavor linger after you swallow. One dash of Angostura also pulls a cloying sour back into balance.
Skip them in an Old Fashioned and you've made diluted whiskey.
Buy these three and stop: they cover most classics.
Angostura aromatic. It's the one with the yellow cap and the oversized label (the story goes it was a sizing mix-up they never fixed). It tastes of clove, allspice, cinnamon, and bitter root, and it goes in the Old Fashioned, Manhattan, and most whiskey or rum drinks. A recipe that just says "bitters" means Angostura.
Peychaud's. The bright red New Orleans bitter: lighter, more anise and cherry, less clove. Non-negotiable in a Sazerac; sub Angostura and it's a different drink.
Orange bitters. Made from citrus oil, dried peel, and gentian (a bitter root), they lighten stirred whiskey drinks where Angostura feels heavy. And yes, they belong in a Martini: plenty of pre-Prohibition specs call for them. Regan's No. 6 and Angostura Orange both work.
Once you have those, add mole bitters (Bittermens Xocolatl Mole) for stirred tequila and aged rum, and celery bitters for a Bloody Mary. When Angostura has nothing left to teach you, Bittercube Bolivar or The Bitter Truth's aromatics spin the same idea with different spice. Skip the dozens of single-flavor bitters until a recipe asks for one.
Two dashes is the default for a stirred drink like a Manhattan. A big drink that takes on a lot of water gets three or four, since ice mutes bitters, while a soft Martini or a Bamboo (dry sherry and dry vermouth) gets one. A Pisco Sour gets three to five drops on the foam, for aroma.
A modifier is a liqueur, fortified wine, or amaro (an Italian bitter liqueur; the plural is amari), usually poured by the barspoon, up to ¾ oz. Vermouth is a modifier too, and Vermouth and Fortified Wines covers it.
Maraschino is distilled from Marasca cherries, pits and all, and tastes nothing like the red cocktail cherry. Cherry Heering, a sweet cherry liqueur, won't stand in. Go easy: a quarter ounce can take over a drink.
Chartreuse has the best paperwork on the shelf. In 1605 the nobleman François Hannibal d'Estrées gave the Carthusian monks near Paris a manuscript for an "elixir of long life." They settled the recipe as the Elixir Végétal in 1764, and the liqueurs grew out of it. The monks put the count at 130 plants.
Absinthe was banned in the U.S. in 1912 on bad science about thujone, the wormwood compound blamed for "absinthism." It came back in 2007, with thujone capped at 10 ppm. Today it's a rinse: swirl a few drops to coat the glass, then dump the rest. Buy Pernod Absinthe ($60) or St. George Absinthe Verte ($75). Or use Herbsaint, the New Orleans anise liqueur made as absinthe's stand-in after the ban; it's lower proof and has no grand wormwood, the plant absinthe is named for.
The exception to the rinse rule is Death in the Afternoon, Hemingway's contribution to the 1935 book So Red the Nose: a jigger of absinthe in a Champagne glass, topped with iced Champagne "until it attains the proper opalescent milkiness." He suggested drinking three to five. Don't.
Campari is the bitter backbone of the Negroni and the Boulevardier. Its red came from carmine, a dye made from crushed cochineal insects, until 2006 in most markets. If you like its bitterness, the amari (Averna, Cynar, Fernet, Montenegro) are your next rabbit hole.
Aperol is the softer option (11% to Campari's 24%, and less bitter). It's also the spritz bottle: 3 parts prosecco, 2 Aperol, 1 soda, per the International Bartenders Association spec. In a Negroni it's a pale, sweet thing with no edge.
Orange liqueur mostly goes by two names: triple sec, which today usually means clear and dry (Cointreau is one), and curaçao, which usually means the barrel-aged or blue kind.
Cointreau (40%): clear, dry orange peel. The standard for a Margarita or Sidecar.
Pierre Ferrand Dry Curaçao: barrel-aged and deeper. Use it when an older spec says "curaçao," as in a Mai Tai.
Grand Marnier: Cognac-based and sweeter. Fine in a Sidecar, heavy in a Margarita.
Generic triple sec: usually 15 to 25% ABV and thin. Under $10, it makes Margaritas taste like candy.
Spend it in this order: Cointreau, Campari, Luxardo, Green Chartreuse if you can find it, a small absinthe, then Bénédictine. Add a base spirit (Whiskey Decoded, Gin Decoded), a vermouth, and the starter three, and those bottles build 30+ classics. The rest is citrus and ice. Shake or Stir? says which technique each drink wants.